In a move that stunned market participants, the committee overseeing the S&P Dow Jones Indices rejected MicroStrategy’s inclusion in the benchmark index this past Friday. The business intelligence firm, which recently rebranded as Strategy Inc., was passed over despite meeting all formal technical requirements for admission, including sufficient market capitalization and four consecutive profitable quarters. Instead, the coveted spots were awarded to Robinhood, AppLovin, and Emcor Group.
This exclusion represents a significant setback for the company. Inclusion would have compelled index-tracking funds to purchase its stock, and market experts had projected potential inflows of approximately $16 billion. The disappointment triggered an immediate sell-off, sending the company’s shares tumbling in after-hours trading.
A High-Stakes Strategy Faces Scrutiny
The decision is widely interpreted as a pointed critique of MicroStrategy’s singular focus. While the traditional financial market shows it a cold shoulder, the company continues to aggressively pursue its Bitcoin acquisition strategy. It now holds a colossal 214,400 Bitcoin, a stash valued at over $70 billion and the largest of any publicly traded corporation worldwide.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Strategy?
However, this massive expansion has come at a considerable cost. To fund its relentless Bitcoin purchases, MicroStrategy has systematically diluted existing shareholders through substantial secondary stock offerings. The company recently broke its own promise not to sell shares below a specific valuation multiple, underscoring the immense pressure to continue funding its crypto acquisitions.
Growing Disconnect Between Assets and Valuation
A particularly troubling trend for investors is the growing divergence between the company’s Bitcoin holdings and its stock performance. Although the Bitcoin treasury has more than doubled since the stock’s peak in late 2024, the share price has failed to keep pace. Consequently, each share now represents a significantly larger underlying Bitcoin value, a fact the market has so far refused to reward appropriately.
The S&P committee’s verdict appears to signal deep institutional skepticism regarding the sustainability of MicroStrategy’s high-risk, crypto-centric business model. The subsequent downward trend in the stock price following the news highlights a critical moment of reassessment for the pioneering Bitcoin corporate holder.
Ad
Strategy Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Strategy Analysis from September 21 delivers the answer:
The latest Strategy figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Strategy investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from September 21.
Strategy: Buy or sell? Read more here...
