The First Trust BuyWrite Income ETF (FTHI) employs a covered call strategy designed to generate consistent income for investors through option premiums. This approach involves maintaining a portfolio of U.S. stocks across various market capitalizations while simultaneously writing call options against the S&P 500 Index. However, current market conditions are testing the resilience of this income-focused methodology.
Performance Gap Emerges in Bull Market
Recent performance data reveals a significant divergence between FTHI and broader market benchmarks. Year-to-date, the ETF has delivered a 6.24% return, while its one-year performance stands at 10.66%. These figures substantially trail the S&P 500’s gains of 14.8% and 17.6% over the same periods, respectively. This performance gap highlights the potential opportunity cost of the covered call approach during strong bullish markets, where capped upside may limit participation in full market rallies.
Despite this performance differential, investor confidence appears sustained. The fund maintains robust liquidity with average daily trading volume exceeding 500,000 shares. Recent flows show substantial investor interest, with net inflows of $283.95 million over three months boosting total assets under management to $1.70 billion, positioning FTHI as an established player in the covered call ETF space.
Portfolio Construction Reveals Tech-Heavy Tilt
While the fund holds 204 individual positions suggesting diversification, concentration risk emerges upon closer examination. The top ten holdings constitute a substantial 39.46% of total assets, with clear dominance by technology giants:
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying First Trust BuyWrite Income ETF?
- NVIDIA Corp: 7.49%
- Microsoft Corp: 7.01%
- Apple Inc.: 6.50%
- Amazon.com Inc.: 3.18%
- Meta Platforms Inc.: 3.04%
Sector allocation further confirms this technological orientation, with 34.88% allocated to technology stocks and an additional 10.81% to communication services. This heavy reliance on digital economy companies means the fund’s performance remains closely tied to the fortunes of mega-cap tech leaders like NVIDIA and Microsoft.
Strategy Mechanics and Competitive Landscape
FTHI’s methodology allocates up to 20% of portfolio assets to its covered call strategy, seeking to capitalize on periods of moderate volatility when option premiums can provide attractive income streams. The approach involves mathematical optimization for dividend stock selection combined with active management of option positions.
The competitive environment for covered call ETFs has intensified, with products like the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI) and Global X S&P 500 Covered Call ETF (XYLD) vying for investor attention. While all three funds employ covered call strategies, they differ meaningfully in expense ratios, performance history, and underlying portfolio composition.
The central question for FTHI remains whether its active management approach and dividend stock optimization can compensate for its persistent performance gap relative to the broader market. Recent fund flows suggest continued investor interest in its income-generating capabilities, but the strategy’s long-term viability depends on navigating the tension between yield generation and capital appreciation in evolving market conditions.
Ad
First Trust BuyWrite Income ETF Stock: Buy or Sell?! New First Trust BuyWrite Income ETF Analysis from December 19 delivers the answer:
The latest First Trust BuyWrite Income ETF figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for First Trust BuyWrite Income ETF investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from December 19.
First Trust BuyWrite Income ETF: Buy or sell? Read more here...
