Barrick Gold Shares Tumble Despite Record Earnings and Dividend Surge

Investors delivered a harsh verdict on Barrick Gold Corporation’s latest financial results, sending shares down more than 8% in a stark contrast to the company’s reported performance. The sell-off occurred even as the mining giant announced a near-doubling of its profit and a significant dividend increase, with concerns over future production and a contentious dispute with rival Newmont overshadowing the strong figures.

Operational Peak and Shareholder Returns

The final quarter of 2025 represented an operational high point for the gold producer. Barrick reported adjusted earnings per share of $1.04, comfortably exceeding the average analyst estimate of $0.87. Quarterly revenue reached $6.0 billion. For the full year, the company’s free cash flow surged by almost 200 percent to $3.9 billion.

This robust financial position is translating into direct benefits for shareholders. A new dividend policy commits to distributing 50% of the free cash flow. Consequently, the declared dividend for the past quarter is $0.42 per share, a substantial increase from the previous $0.18. Additionally, the company allocated $1.5 billion toward share buybacks over the last year.

Cautious Outlook Sparks Investor Anxiety

The market’s negative reaction was primarily triggered by management’s guidance for the current business year. For 2026, Barrick forecasts gold production in a range of 2.90 to 3.25 million ounces. This projection falls below the previous year’s output of 3.26 million ounces. This conservative estimate, coupled with forecasts of rising operational costs, prompted the wave of selling pressure.

Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Barrick Mining?

Simultaneously, the company is advancing plans to spin off its North American assets into a new publicly traded entity, referred to as “NewCo.” This initial public offering, targeted for completion by the end of 2026, is set to include stakes in key operations such as the Nevada Gold Mines and the Pueblo Viejo mine. Barrick intends to retain a majority ownership stake in the newly formed company.

Newmont Dispute Poses Strategic Threat

The planned IPO is facing serious opposition from partner Newmont. The competitor has issued a formal Notice of Default to Barrick, alleging mismanagement of their shared Nevada joint venture. Newmont contends that the performance and asset value in Nevada have deteriorated over the past six years.

This conflict introduces significant risk to Barrick’s strategic agenda. Should the planned spin-off be legally interpreted as a change of control, Newmont could attempt to exercise a right of first refusal on the assets involved. Such a move would severely disrupt the intended structure of NewCo.

Barrick’s leadership now faces mounting pressure. While the company’s balance sheet is strong, the successful execution of the separation remains a critical variable for the stock’s valuation. The share price trajectory for 2026 will largely depend on whether an agreement can be reached with Newmont or if the legal dispute ultimately blocks the strategic reorganization.