The world’s largest corporate holder of Bitcoin is confronting significant headwinds despite the enormous paper gains on its digital asset holdings. MicroStrategy, the business intelligence company that transformed itself into a Bitcoin acquisition vehicle, finds itself under intense scrutiny from market analysts. This criticism emerges at a curious juncture—precisely as the value of its Bitcoin treasury has surged past the $71 billion mark.
Staggering Paper Profits Drive Quarterly Results
MicroStrategy’s second-quarter 2025 financial performance was dominated by its cryptocurrency strategy. The company reported operating earnings of $14.03 billion, representing a staggering 7,000 percent year-over-year increase. This extraordinary surge was primarily attributable to unrealized gains on its vast digital asset portfolio.
The firm’s Bitcoin holdings now stand at 628,791 coins, acquired at an average purchase price of approximately $73,277 per Bitcoin. Their total investment in these assets amounts to $46.07 billion. With Bitcoin posting a 25 percent return since the beginning of the year, the company’s core investment thesis appears, on the surface, to be delivering results.
Wall Street Analysts Voice Serious Concerns
Despite these paper gains, prominent Wall Street voices are raising red flags. Monness analyst Gus Gala recently reaffirmed his “Sell” rating on MicroStrategy shares, setting a price target roughly 50 percent below current trading levels. His primary concern centers on the company’s funding mechanism for additional Bitcoin purchases.
Gala and other critics highlight what they describe as a “dilution feedback loop,” where MicroStrategy finances new Bitcoin acquisitions through issuing additional shares. This practice came into sharp focus during the second quarter alone, when the company raised approximately $6.8 billion through various equity offerings, prompting investor concerns about continuous share dilution.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Strategy?
Extreme Volatility Mirrors Crypto Markets
MicroStrategy’s stock price behavior closely tracks that of its primary asset, exhibiting the characteristic volatility of a Bitcoin proxy security. The shares experienced 76 separate price movements exceeding five percent during the past year, reflecting the inherent instability of the cryptocurrency market. Trading has ranged from $113.69 to $543 per share—an exceptionally wide band.
This dependency becomes particularly evident during Bitcoin price corrections. When the cryptocurrency declined from $117,000 to under $112,000, MicroStrategy shares responded with disproportionately sharp downward movements.
Aggressive Forecasts Reveal Single-Asset Strategy
Company leadership remains outwardly confident despite mounting criticism. Management has projected 2025 operating earnings of $34 billion alongside earnings per share of $80. These ambitious forecasts rest entirely on one crucial assumption: Bitcoin reaching $150,000 by year’s end.
This optimistic outlook underscores both MicroStrategy’s fundamental investment thesis and its most significant vulnerability—complete dependence on the price trajectory of a single volatile digital asset. The ultimate success or failure of this concentrated bet will determine the financial future of the company and its shareholders.
Ad
Strategy Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Strategy Analysis from October 13 delivers the answer:
The latest Strategy figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Strategy investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from October 13.
Strategy: Buy or sell? Read more here...
