The timing could not be more awkward. On July 14, Netflix beamed its first-ever MLB Home Run Derby to a global audience, marking a decisive break with traditional cable and signalling that live sports are now a core pillar of its growth strategy. Yet the same week, data showed that weekly global streaming minutes on the platform had fallen for a third consecutive period, down more than 39% year-on-year — a slump analysts attribute largely to the competing draw of the FIFA World Cup.
That contradiction sets the stage for one of the most closely watched earnings calls in the streaming sector. Netflix reports second-quarter results after the bell on July 16, and the options market is bracing for a swing of up to 8%, well above the historical average of around 6%. Despite four straight post-earnings declines, call volume has recently run nearly three times that of puts, suggesting speculative bets on an upside surprise.
Analyst Targets Slashed, but BofA Stands Firm
A dozen analysts have trimmed their price targets in recent weeks. Morgan Stanley cut its target from $115 to $90 but kept an overweight rating, arguing that churn following a March U.S. price hike will prove temporary. Barclays lowered its target to $85, KeyBanc to $92, and Bernstein to $100, with the latter pointing to headwinds from the World Cup. Oppenheimer reduced its target from $120 to $100.
Bank of America, however, has held its ground, reaffirming a buy rating and a $125 target. It expects results largely in line with consensus and is focused on second-half guidance, engagement trends and potential M&A. Overall, 24 of 32 analysts tracked cover Netflix as a buy, with an average target of roughly $112.70.
Stock Under Pressure as Technicals Flash Caution
Netflix shares traded at €65.04 on Wednesday, up 0.99% from the prior close of €64.40, but the short-term trend remains weak. The stock has fallen 1.71% over the past week and 7.74% over the past month. The relative strength index stands at 42.8, indicating neither oversold nor overbought conditions, while annualised 30-day volatility of 36.75% points to elevated uncertainty ahead of the print.
The previous session’s close of €64.40 put the shares well off their all-time high of $134.12 reached on June 30, 2025. The market capitalisation stands at roughly €269.72 billion. The June sell-off had already taken the stock to a 52-week low.
Ad-Tier Momentum vs. Engagement Worries
The central debate among analysts is whether Netflix should be read as an advertising growth story or a case of fading user engagement. The ad-supported tier now counts more than 250 million monthly active users, and ad revenue is on track to roughly double to $3 billion this year. Wedbush’s Alicia Reese argues that ad momentum overshadows engagement concerns because advertisers can reach audiences across all subscription tiers and sports ad pricing remains stable.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Netflix?
Still, the engagement data is hard to ignore. The third consecutive weekly decline in global streaming minutes, driven by World Cup viewership on rival platforms, has fuelled scepticism. Netflix management has pre-emptively flagged margin pressure for the second quarter, with the operating margin expected at 32.6%, down from 34.1% in the same period last year. For the full year, the company guides for revenue between $50.7 billion and $51.7 billion, an operating margin of 31.5%, and growth of 12–14% — underpinned by new subscribers, targeted price increases, and the ad business.
Consensus estimates point to Q2 revenue of $12.58 billion, up 13.5% year-on-year, and earnings of $0.79 per share. For the third quarter, analysts project $13 billion in revenue and EPS of $0.84.
The Home Run Derby: A New Chapter With Mixed Reviews
The July 14 broadcast of the T-Mobile Home Run Derby from Citizens Bank Park in Philadelphia was the first time the event aired exclusively on a streaming platform rather than ESPN, cable television or MLB.TV. Netflix holds the exclusive rights, part of a broader MLB partnership that began on March 25 with the season opener between the New York Yankees and San Francisco Giants. A “Field of Dreams” game between the Minnesota Twins and Philadelphia Phillies at the Iowa cornfield stadium is scheduled for August 13.
The exclusive switch, however, created friction. Many MLB.TV subscribers assumed their existing packages would cover the Derby as usual — they did not, and there was no workaround via cable or ESPN apps. The on-air appearance of comedian Will Ferrell also drew criticism from some fans, one of whom lamented how far the broadcast had strayed from the style of legendary commentator Chris Berman.
For MLB, the logic is clear: the partnership offers access to a younger, international audience across more than 190 countries and 50 languages. For Netflix, live sports — alongside advertising — now serves as the second pillar of its growth strategy, designed to stabilise engagement and attract premium ad dollars.
What to Watch When Netflix Reports
Investors will focus on three key areas: the trajectory of ad-tier monetisation, engagement data since the World Cup began, and management’s outlook for the second half. With live events and sports programming — including the upcoming Field of Dreams game — set to ramp up, Netflix will need to demonstrate that its sports strategy can meaningfully reverse the engagement trend rather than simply add another cost line.
Given the unusual mix of a live-debut milestone and a concurrent viewership slump, this earnings report offers a clear test of whether Netflix can sell its sports-and-ads narrative to a market that has grown increasingly cautious. The options market is betting on fireworks one way or the other.
Ad
Netflix Stock: Buy or Sell?! New Netflix Analysis from September 15 delivers the answer:
The latest Netflix figures speak for themselves: Urgent action needed for Netflix investors. Is it worth buying or should you sell? Find out what to do now in the current free analysis from September 15.
Netflix: Buy or sell? Read more here...
